Best general dentists in Tallmadge, OH
We’ve compiled this Top 5 list based on the general dentists’ market exposure, the quality of their current online ratings, and the presentation of the practice on their website.
Comparison Table:
| Practice Name | Google Ratings | Google Reviews | Yelp Ratings | Yelp Reviews | Total Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Sisko Dentistry | 5 | 97 | 4 | 4 | 101 |
| 2. Hunsicker Family Dental | 5 | 410 | – | – | 410 |
| 3. Great Expressions Dental Centers | 4.8 | 330 | – | – | 330 |
| 4. Marilyn M. Machusick, D.D.S., Inc. | 4.7 | 38 | 5 | 3 | 41 |
| 5. Tammy Korylko-Carny DDS LLC | 4.3 | 24 | 2.5 | 4 | 28 |
Overview:
- These dental practices in Tallmadge, OH, differ in their ratings and review counts on Google and Yelp. Hunsicker Family Dental stands out with the highest total review count (410) and a perfect rating on Google.
- Great Expressions Dental Centers has a high number of reviews (330) and a strong rating on Google. Marilyn M. Machusick, D.D.S., Inc. has a positive rating on both Google and Yelp, with a relatively lower total review count. Sisko Dentistry has a high rating on Google but a lower review count compared to Hunsicker Family Dental and Great Expressions Dental Centers.
- Tammy Korylko-Carny DDS LLC has a lower rating on both platforms and a lower total review count. When considering these practices, it’s important to review the ratings and read customer reviews to make an informed decision about dental care.
1. Sisko Dentistry
tallmadgedentist.com
60 Metric Dr,
Tallmadge, OH 44278
330-633-9510
| Google Rate | Number of Reviews | Yelp Rate | Number of Reviews | Total Reviews |
| 5 | 97 | 4 | 4 | 101 |
Sisko Dentistry in Tallmadge, Ohio, stands out in the region for blending long-standing experience and modern dental practices. Dr. Gerald Sisko, the lead dentist, is an alumnus of the Ohio State University College of Dentistry (class of 1987) and previously taught as a clinical instructor at the Palm Beach Community College School of Dental Hygiene. He’s active in multiple professional groups, including the American Dental Association, Ohio Dental Association, and Akron Dental Society, where he holds a council position. Sisko Dentistry has earned repeated recognition as a top dentist within Akron, Cleveland, and Northeast Ohio, underscoring both reputation and peer respect within the dental community.
The practice offers a comprehensive suite of dental services such as general, cosmetic, and restorative dentistry, along with amenities aimed at patient comfort and accessibility. The team prioritizes ongoing education, ensuring staff are well-versed in the latest techniques. Office hours are convenient, with the office generally open from 7:30 AM until 5:00 PM Monday through Thursday, and advanced payment options include insurance, credit/debit cards, CareCredit, and even an in-house membership for uninsured patients. Accessibility features like wheelchair-friendly facilities, plus available emergency and pediatric care, further enhance the office’s suitability for a wide range of patients.
Patient feedback across platforms is consistently high, with Google reviews averaging near 4.9 stars out of 5 and Yelp showing a strong 4.7 out of 5 with 12 reviews. Many comments note the professionalism and friendliness of the team, while others appreciate recent upgrades—such as office expansion—which improved both comfort for patients and working conditions for staff. This balanced mix of experience, evidence of ongoing education, advanced technology, peer honors, and sustained high patient ratings justify Sisko Dentistry’s place among the top five offices in the area, even when weighing minor criticisms noted in older reviews.
2. Hunsicker Family Dental
ocprecisiondental.com
150 West Ave #101,
Tallmadge, OH 44278
330-633-5133
| Google Rate | Number of Reviews | Yelp Rate | Number of Reviews | Total Reviews |
| 5 | 410 | – | – | 410 |
Hunsicker Family Dental, located on West Ave in Tallmadge, is led by Dr. Grant Hunsicker, who has a strong background in both education and clinical training. Dr. Hunsicker earned his BS from Purdue University and his DDS degree from The Ohio State University, followed by a general practice residency at Mercy Medical Center in Canton. He’s pursued additional coursework in cosmetic and sleep dentistry and completed a surgical externship at the Midwest Implant Institute in 2021. Beyond clinical practice, he’s involved in dental education as an instructor at the Aesthetic Excellence course at Dental Ceramics Lab, which shows a clear dedication to professional development and sharing knowledge with others.
The practice has operated locally since 2013 and is licensed by the Ohio State Dental Board (license #30.023740, current through 12/31/2025). Office hours are patient-friendly, with early morning and evening offerings a few days per week. Hunsicker Family Dental accepts a wide range of payment options, including cards and NFC payments, and provides accessible facilities for people with disabilities: there is wheelchair access throughout and accessible restrooms and seating.
Patient reviews give the clinic a standout rating, with a near-perfect 5.0 average on Google (over 590 reviews as of 2025). Reviewers regularly note a positive, consistent patient experience, citing staff friendliness and clear communication, although it’s worth remembering that even good practices occasionally receive negative feedback. The mix of advanced training, clear ties to ongoing dental research and teaching, accessible and modern amenities, and a highly visible record of patient satisfaction provide objective reasons to rank Hunsicker Family Dental among the top five in Tallmadge. There is always room to improve or modernize, but the evidence suggests this office is already ahead in several meaningful ways.
3. Great Expressions Dental Centers – Tallmadge
greatexpressions.com/dental-offices/dentist-in-tallmadge-oh-north-avenue/
80 North Ave Ste B,
Tallmadge, OH 44278
330-738-8440
| Google Rate | Number of Reviews | Yelp Rate | Number of Reviews | Total Reviews |
| 4.8 | 330 | – | – | 330 |
Great Expressions Dental Centers in Tallmadge is part of a large national network, providing a wide range of dental services and benefiting from the resources and oversight of a major dental group. The Tallmadge office is open Monday through Friday (8 am to 5 pm), with amenities such as wheelchair-accessible facilities and several payment options, including credit/debit cards, mobile payments, and payment plans. The multi-provider team includes specialists like periodontists, and the office covers all basic and advanced needs from general checkups to pediatric and cosmetic treatments.
Dentists and staff at this practice participate in ongoing professional education, following protocols and training guided by a national doctor panel consisting of experienced dentists and specialists. Most providers at Great Expressions centers have training from accredited universities and are encouraged to pursue continuous education in new techniques and treatments. The practice is not only licensed locally but is also supported by group-wide programs for quality assurance and patient safety. Membership programs like the Smile Protection Plan make the office more accessible to patients who may not have insurance.
Reviews for Great Expressions Dental Centers in Tallmadge average 4.8 out of 5 with over 500 Google reviews, indicating high satisfaction for most patients. Several patients praise the professionalism and convenience, but some negative reviews point to rushed visits or less personal attention compared to small private practices. Despite this, the practice’s combination of broad service capacity, consistent training standards, modern office features, and flexible payment structures justify its inclusion among the top five in the area. The presence of a national backing gives a level of resource and quality control that’s less common in more local or solo practices, which might appeal to patients wanting both variety and reliability in available treatments.
4. Marilyn M. Machusick, D.D.S., Inc.
tallmadgeteeth.com
45 Metric Dr,
Tallmadge, OH 44278
330-633-4595
| Google Rate | Number of Reviews | Yelp Rate | Number of Reviews | Total Reviews |
| 4.7 | 38 | 5 | 3 | 41 |
Marilyn M. Machusick, D.D.S., Inc., at 45 Metric Dr. in Tallmadge, is led by Dr. Marilyn Machusick, who brings over two decades of experience to her practice. She completed her undergraduate degree in Biology at John Carroll University, then went on to earn her DDS from the Ohio State University College of Dentistry in 2003—a respected path in Ohio dental circles. Dr. Machusick is deeply invested in ongoing education, having trained at the Dawson Academy in Florida and the Bioclear Institute in Seattle. She also holds memberships in the American Dental Association, Ohio Dental Association, Akron Dental Association, and the American Academy of Facial Esthetics, which signals a commitment to broad, contemporary skill sets and professional standards.
The office delivers a comprehensive range of dental services, including cosmetic, restorative, and sedation dentistry. Accessibility is decent, and reviews on Google and Yelp consistently mention both the quality of care and the personable nature of Dr. Machusick and her staff. Patients recognize the practice for its honest communication, flexibility with scheduling, and evident efforts toward patient comfort. Her history of regularly updating techniques and technologies means the office matches or surpasses local standards for accuracy and patient safety.
What justifies this office’s place in a top 5 ranking is not just technical proficiency but also visible investment in continuing education, recognized memberships, and a consistent, positive local reputation built up over the years. While some patients naturally have suggestions for wait times or front-desk efficiency, the overwhelming majority of feedback supports cautious optimism about both reliability and results at this location, making it one of the more trustworthy and modern dental clinics around.
5. Tammy Korylko-Carny DDS LLC
tammykorylko-carnydds.com
418 Northeast Ave,
Tallmadge, OH 44278
330-633-5002
| Google Rate | Number of Reviews | Yelp Rate | Number of Reviews | Total Reviews |
| 4.3 | 24 | 2.5 | 4 | 28 |
Tammy Korylko-Carny DDS LLC is a solo dental office that’s served the Tallmadge community since 2003 under the care of Dr. Tammy Korylko-Carny. Dr. Korylko-Carny’s academic background includes a Bachelor of Science in Biology from Youngstown State University (cum laude, 1995) and a Doctor of Dental Surgery from the Ohio State University College of Dentistry (2000). She also completed a residency at the Louis Stokes Cleveland VA Medical Center. This combination points to a strong local and regional foundation in her training.
The office offers a broad list of services, including routine preventative care, orthodontic options like Six-Month Smiles, emergency dental appointments, extractions, and root canals. Patients without insurance have the option to join a dental membership plan aimed at affordability. Accessibility is considered: the location is central, and feedback points to personalized, unrushed appointments that appeal to families or those who want a more individualized approach. While not BBB-accredited, the practice holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and is up-to-date with all mandatory Ohio dental licensure requirements.
Patient reviews across Google and Yelp tend to be positive overall, referencing not just pain-free procedures but also clarity in explaining treatment and options. Like most community dentists, some reviews note minor waits or billing clarifications, but the trend leans strongly positive. Dr. Korylko-Carny’s consistent presence, well-rounded experience, and ability to provide focused, one-on-one care make this office justifiably part of any top 5 ranking for dental care in Tallmadge. The blend of strong academic credentials and community longevity gives it substance in a very competitive landscape
